The Tax Situation Your Athletes Are Walking Into Unprepared. Why That Is Your Program's Problem and Yours to Solve.
The IRS designated NIL a high-risk enforcement category in 2025. Self-employment tax runs 15.3%. Most college athletes have never filed a tax return. The gap between those facts and your current financial literacy offering is the liability you have not yet priced.
The IRS Has Already Moved
The Internal Revenue Service does not wait for financial literacy programs to catch up with new income categories. Its current guidance on NIL income is unambiguous: all compensation received through name, image, and likeness activity is taxable income, including non-cash compensation received as merchandise, travel, gift cards, or other goods and services at fair market value. Athletes classified as independent contractors report this income on Schedule C and owe self-employment tax at 15.3% on net self-employment income up to $184,500 in 2026.
The February 2026 analysis published by the Texas Society of CPAs documented the consistent pattern tax professionals encounter when advising NIL athletes: no estimated tax payments have been made, self-employment tax is not understood, filing thresholds are unknown, and 1099-NEC forms and W-9 obligations are unfamiliar. The IRS, the analysis noted, considers NIL income as ordinary income but sees it internally as high-risk due to inexperienced taxpayers, significant unreported earnings, non-cash compensation, multi-state issues, and lack of 1099 reporting.
Sources: Texas CPA Society, February 2026; IRS NIL Income Guidance; SDO CPA, April 2026.
The Quarterly Obligation Most Athletes Miss
The federal tax system operates on a pay-as-you-go basis. Employees have taxes withheld from each paycheck automatically. Independent contractors do not. An athlete who receives $40,000 in NIL compensation during a calendar year and makes no estimated tax payments until April 15 of the following year has not deferred a tax obligation. They have incurred underpayment penalties calculated as interest on the amount that should have been paid at each of the four quarterly deadlines: April 15, June 15, September 15, and January 15.
The SDO CPA analysis provides the arithmetic plainly: $40,000 in net NIL income generates $6,120 in self-employment tax alone, before federal income tax at the applicable bracket. For a dependent on a parent's return in the 24% bracket, the combined obligation can approach $16,000 on $40,000 in earnings — a marginal tax rate that most eighteen-year-olds have never encountered and are not prepared to plan around.
Sources: SDO CPA, April 2026; TurboTax NIL Guide, December 2025; Albin Randall Bennett, December 2025.
The 2026 Threshold Change and What It Obscures
Beginning with tax year 2026, the 1099-NEC reporting threshold increases to $2,000 under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. This change is being widely misread by athletes and, in some cases, by the adults advising them. The $2,000 threshold is a paperwork trigger for the paying entity, not a tax exemption for the recipient. An athlete who receives $1,800 in NIL compensation from a local business that does not issue a 1099 still owes federal income tax and self-employment tax on that income.
An athlete earns $40,000 in NIL income across five brand deals in the 2025-26 academic year. No estimated payments are made. At filing in April 2026: self-employment tax of $6,120. Federal income tax at the 22% bracket on $27,050 of taxable income after the standard deduction: approximately $5,951. State income tax at an average 5%: $2,000. Total obligation: approximately $14,000. Plus underpayment penalties on the amounts that should have been paid quarterly. The athlete received $40,000 and owes $14,000-plus at a time of year with no game checks arriving to cover it.
Sources: SDO CPA, April 2026; IRS Underpayment Penalty Guidance; Texas CPA Society, February 2026.
The Multi-State Problem
An athlete who lives in a state without income tax but makes appearances, posts content pursuant to contracts, or performs services in states that do impose income tax may have filing obligations in those states. The jock tax, the principle of taxing income based on where athletic services are performed, is being applied with increasing frequency to college athletes with NIL income. For athletes who transferred schools in 2025 or 2026, part-year residency rules in multiple states create additional complexity. The University of Maryland's TerpTax program has documented multi-state complications as among the most common sources of filing errors in its athlete clientele.
Sources: SDO CPA, April 2026; University of Maryland TerpTax, June 2025; YSBR Tax Guide, February 2025.
What Programs Owe Their Athletes
The question of institutional obligation in NIL financial literacy is not philosophical in 2026. Programs that invited athletes into a $2.75 billion commercial market, facilitated their access to brand deals and institutional revenue sharing, and provided no systematic financial literacy support have created the predictable outcome: athletes with IRS obligations they cannot meet, compliance failures they cannot correct retroactively, and financial situations directly traceable to institutional decisions that prioritized deal volume over athlete outcomes.
The standard is defined not by the House settlement but by the recruiting promises programs made and the institutional duty of care that follows from inviting eighteen-year-olds into commercial financial relationships with material tax consequences. Programs that provide a how NIL works overview at freshman orientation and nothing further are not meeting that standard.
Financial literacy is not a nice-to-have in an NIL program. It is the component that determines whether athletes leave your program better off financially than when they arrived. That outcome is within your institution's control. Whether it happens is a choice your program is making right now, by action or by omission.
ROLA builds the business infrastructure behind athletic programs, NIL collectives, and the institutions developing the next generation of athlete-entrepreneurs. The strategy session is where that work begins.
Book a Strategy Session →